The High-Volume High-Wire Act: Decoding the Premier Pools & Spas Construction Supervision Model

For pool professionals aiming to transition from routine maintenance and service work (like that offered by ASP or Puddle Pool Services) into the lucrative, high-ticket world of pool and spa construction, Premier Pools & Spas (PFM) offers a distinct, supervisory franchise model. Operating under the dual brands "Premier Pools & Spas" and "Pinnacle Pools & Spas", PFM franchisees focus not on hands-on building, but on the crucial tasks of marketing, selling, and supervising construction projects, which sets their financial profile far apart from typical service franchises.

The financial rewards for success in this model are substantial. For the 104 franchised outlets open for the full year 2023, PFM reported an Average Gross Revenue of $3,744,777 and a Median Gross Revenue of $2,528,852. These figures, representing gross sales before expenses and profitability, demonstrate the massive revenue potential inherent in the construction segment compared to the service and retail averages reported by brands like Poolwerx ($1,244,222 Average Gross Revenue).

The Asset-Light, Contractor-Heavy Approach

The PFM System business model hinges on delegation: franchisees do not engage in the actual construction or remodeling of swimming pools and spas. Instead, they are mandated to hire contractors who must be "properly licensed and adequately insured" to perform those services. This structure keeps the estimated initial investment relatively low for a construction-adjacent business, ranging between $58,950 and $119,000. This low investment includes the $45,000 paid to the franchisor or affiliate.

However, unlike ASP, which offers structured financing and significant fee forgiveness for conversion candidates, PFM explicitly states that it does not offer direct or indirect financing or guarantee any financial obligations, requiring prospective franchisees to secure their own funding. Furthermore, franchisees must purchase "all or nearly all" inventory and supplies from franchisor-designated suppliers, potentially limiting procurement flexibility.

The Strict Nonexclusive Territory and MAPR Risk

While PFM grants a specific geographic area (generally encompassing at least 1 to 4 counties), the territory granted is nonexclusive. This lack of full exclusivity immediately distinguishes PFM from territory models used by brands like ASP or PPS, which grant exclusive territories.

PFM's limited protection is heavily conditioned on performance through the Minimum Annual Performance Requirements (MAPR). Franchisees must achieve minimum annual Gross Revenues for each of their assigned "Pool Types" (gunite, fiberglass, and/or vinyl) during every successive 12-month period. Failure to meet the MAPR is a high-stakes failure: the franchisor reserves the right to unilaterally reduce the size of the Territory, eliminate limited territorial rights, eliminate one or more of the assigned Pool Types, or even terminate the Franchise Agreement by giving 30 days' written notice.

The competitive landscape is further complicated by PFM's corporate structure. The franchisor explicitly reserves the right for its affiliate, PPSF, LLC (Premier Pool Service), to "develop and operate, and license third parties to develop and operate, businesses to market, sell, and provide cleaning, maintenance, repair, and other services for swimming pools and spas" anywhere, regardless of whether such businesses are located in or outside the Territory. This means a PFM construction franchisee, focused on multi-million dollar sales, may see a sister cleaning/maintenance brand actively competing for recurring service revenue within their own nonexclusive area.

Navigating High-Volume Litigation and Regulatory Risks

A critical risk factor detailed in PFM's FDD is the extensive litigation history disclosed in Item 3. The document lists multiple ongoing customer complaints and lawsuits from 2023 and 2024, generally alleging issues stemming from the pool construction process. Common claims include breach of contract, negligence, fraud, misrepresentation, construction defects, and violations of consumer protection acts. Importantly, these suits frequently name the franchisor (Premier Franchise Management LLC) alongside the local franchisee, underscoring the legal exposure inherent in supervising high-value construction projects.

Additionally, regulatory breaches have occurred: in 2021, PFM and its CEO entered into an Assurance of Discontinuance with the New York Attorney General related to selling a franchise while unregistered in the state, resulting in a $10,000 penalty and costs.

Post-termination non-competition clauses are broad, prohibiting former franchisees from involvement in any competitive business that sells, constructs, remodels, or supervises construction within 50 miles of the Territory or 50 miles of any other franchisee's territory for a period of two years.

In essence, Premier Pools & Spas offers a high-reward franchising path built on efficient project supervision, capable of generating exceptional gross revenue figures. However, this opportunity requires the operator to meet stringent, quantifiable annual sales quotas (MAPR) to maintain their limited territorial rights, navigate competition from corporate affiliates, and manage the significant liability exposure associated with third-party construction work—a high-stakes environment where success is defined by consistent, million-dollar performance.

---

Compare Other Pool Franchise FDDs

• ASP - America's Swimming Pool Company Analysis
• California Pools Construction Supervision Model Analysis
• Poolwerx Hybrid Mobile & Retail Model Analysis
• Puddle Pool Services Focused Service Model Analysis