Hayward H-Series Not Heating or Heating Too Slowly: Complete Troubleshooting Guide

Understanding Heating Problems

When a Hayward H-Series heater appears to not heat or heats slowly, the issue rarely involves complete heater failure. More often, the heater is working but other factors prevent efficient heat transfer to the pool. Understanding normal heating rates and proper diagnosis is crucial.

Normal Heating Expectations

Heater Size	Pool Size	Expected Temp Rise	Time to Raise 10°F
150,000 BTU	10,000 gal	1.5°F/hour	6-7 hours
200,000 BTU	15,000 gal	1.3°F/hour	7-8 hours
250,000 BTU	20,000 gal	1.2°F/hour	8-9 hours
400,000 BTU	30,000 gal	1.3°F/hour	7-8 hours

Categories of Heating Problems

1. No Temperature Rise (Heater Running)

• Heater fires and runs continuously
• No error codes displayed
• Pool temperature doesn't increase
• Usually indicates total bypass or massive heat loss

2. Insufficient Temperature Rise

• Some heating occurs but slower than expected
• Temperature rises but can't reach setpoint
• Often due to undersizing or partial bypass

3. Intermittent Heating

• Heater cycles on and off frequently
• Temperature fluctuates
• May indicate thermostat or flow issues

Initial Diagnostic Steps

Step 1: Verify Heater Operation

1. Confirm heater display shows "HEATING" or flame symbol
2. Listen for combustion sounds
3. Feel exhaust vent for hot air
4. Check inlet/outlet pipes for temperature difference
5. No heating indication = troubleshoot ignition issues first

Step 2: Measure Temperature Rise

1. Use accurate thermometer at inlet and outlet
2. Run heater for 5 minutes to stabilize
3. Measure temperature at both points
4. Calculate difference (ΔT)

Step 3: Calculate Actual BTU Output

Common Causes and Solutions

Bypass Issues (Most Common - 40%)

Internal Bypass Stuck Open

• Automatic bypass diverts flow around heat exchanger
• Spring failure keeps bypass open
• Solution: Replace bypass assembly or convert to manual

External Bypass Misadjusted

• Manual bypass valve set incorrectly
• Too much water bypassing heater
• Solution: Close bypass valve completely, then adjust for proper flow

Testing Bypass Function

1. Close external bypass completely
2. Check temperature rise
3. If rise improves significantly, bypass was issue
4. Adjust for 6-10°F rise

Undersized Heater (25%)

Calculating Proper Heater Size

Factors Affecting Size Requirements

• Surface area: Larger surface = more heat loss
• Wind exposure: Increases evaporation
• Night temperatures: Cold nights require more heating
• Cover usage: No cover = 50% more heating needed
• Desired temperature: Higher temps = exponentially more heat loss

Heat Loss Issues (20%)

Excessive Evaporation

• Evaporation accounts for 70% of heat loss
• Worse with low humidity, high wind
• Solution: Install pool cover, windbreaks

Ground Water Cooling

• High water table cools pool through shell
• Worse with vinyl liner pools
• Solution: Insulate pool walls, maintain higher temperature continuously

Gas/Combustion Problems (10%)

Low Gas Pressure

• Reduces BTU output significantly
• Heater runs but produces less heat
• Check inlet pressure during operation
• Solution: Upsize gas line or adjust regulator

Altitude Derating

• Heaters produce less BTU at altitude
• 4% reduction per 1000 feet elevation
• May need larger heater at high altitude

Dirty Burners

• Carbon buildup reduces efficiency
• Spider webs block gas orifices
• Solution: Annual burner cleaning

Heat Exchanger Issues (5%)

Scale Buildup

• Calcium deposits insulate tubes
• Reduces heat transfer efficiency
• Common with high calcium hardness
• Solution: Chemical cleaning or replacement

Soot Accumulation

• Poor combustion creates soot layer
• Insulates fire side of exchanger
• Solution: Clean exchanger, fix combustion issue

Advanced Diagnostics

Flow Rate Testing

Method 1: Bucket Test

1. Use valve or drain near heater
2. Time filling 5-gallon bucket
3. Calculate GPM: (5 gallons ÷ seconds) × 60
4. Compare to heater minimum flow requirement

Method 2: Temperature Rise Calculation

1. Measure actual temperature rise
2. Use formula: GPM = BTU ÷ (ΔT × 500)
3. Example: 250,000 BTU ÷ (8°F × 500) = 62.5 GPM

Efficiency Testing

Stack Temperature Test

• Measure exhaust temperature
• Should be 80-120°F above water temp
• Higher indicates poor heat transfer
• Lower indicates condensation risk

Gas Consumption Test

1. Read gas meter with only heater running
2. Time one complete revolution
3. Calculate BTU input from meter size
4. Compare to heater rating

Solutions for Poor Heating

Immediate Improvements

• Adjust bypass: Optimize flow through heater
• Clean filter: Improve overall flow rate
• Run pump longer: More heating hours per day
• Use pool cover: Reduce overnight heat loss
• Trim vegetation: Reduce wind exposure

System Upgrades

• Add second heater: For large pools or spas
• Install larger heater: If significantly undersized
• Upgrade gas line: If pressure inadequate
• Add solar heating: Supplement gas heater
• Install automation: Optimize heating cycles

Operational Changes

• Lower temperature expectation: 78-82°F is reasonable
• Heat continuously: Maintaining is easier than recovery
• Time heating cycles: Heat during low-wind periods
• Seasonal adjustment: Accept cooler temps in shoulder seasons

Troubleshooting by Symptom

Heater Runs Constantly, No Temperature Gain

1. Check for complete bypass condition
2. Verify pool not losing water (leak)
3. Measure actual BTU output
4. Check for undersized heater
5. Evaluate heat loss factors

Temperature Rises Then Falls

1. Check thermostat calibration
2. Verify no mixing valves open
3. Look for automatic fill adding cold water
4. Check for groundwater infiltration
5. Evaluate overnight heat loss

Spa Heats But Pool Doesn't

1. Verify valve positions
2. Check for pool suction leak (air dilution)
3. Compare flow rates in each mode
4. Evaluate relative volumes

Calculating Heat Loss

Surface Heat Loss Formula

Factors Multipliers

• No cover: Multiply by 1.5
• Windy location: Multiply by 1.3
• Dry climate: Multiply by 1.2
• Shaded pool: Multiply by 0.8

When Heater Replacement Makes Sense

Consider Replacement When:

• Heater is >75% undersized for pool
• Efficiency has dropped below 70%
• Heat exchanger is severely scaled/damaged
• Multiple major components have failed
• Newer models offer 15%+ efficiency gain

Upgrade Options

• High-efficiency models: 95% vs 82% standard
• Dual heaters: Stage heating for efficiency
• Heat pump hybrid: Gas for quick, heat pump for maintain
• Low NOx models: Required in some areas

Maintenance for Optimal Heating

Annual Service

• Clean burner tray and orifices
• Inspect heat exchanger for scale/soot
• Verify gas pressure and combustion
• Check and adjust bypass settings
• Clean flame sensor and igniter
• Test all safety controls

Seasonal Preparation

• Spring: Clean after winter shutdown
• Summer: Adjust for maximum load
• Fall: Prepare for increased heating demand
• Winter: Protect from freezing if not used

← Back to Universal H-Series Troubleshooting Guide